“BEST INTERESTS” STANDARDS APPLY TO REX & FIDO AS WELL: NEW YORK ADOPTS NEW RULES FOR COMPANION ANIMALS AND PETS IN DIVORCE PROCEEDINGS

James L. Maswick • November 1, 2021

New York has just joined a minority of other states in providing similar protections for pets as it does for children in divorce proceedings as Governor Kathy Hochul has signed the bill in to law. In a normal divorce proceeding, if there is a dispute about custody of a minor child between the parents and no agreement can be reached, the Judge weighs in and makes findings with respect to whom the child is to live with using whatever is in the best interests of the child as a standard for making this decision. This has now been expanded to involve pets who have previously been treated just like personal property with no regard to what is in their best interests. The Court can now be called upon to make a determination of the well-being of companion animals in a custody matter. This analysis about whether the cat or dog goes with what person can include consideration of which of the divorced pet parent has spent the most time caring for the animal, taken the companion animal to the veterinarian, to whom the best is most bonded, and who spent the most time with the animal.


This is a significant change to how these matters have been treated previously, and those involved in a divorce proceeding should understand while they may have anticipated a custody battle over their children, they may now also face one when it comes to their pets.


If you know someone who is in the midst of a divorce proceeding or contemplating divorce, please don’t hesitate to have them contact our office. We are experienced in these matters and can assist as we continue to remain up-to-date on the ins and outs of divorce proceedings, such as this new statute discussed here.

By Flink Maswick Law • October 29, 2026
Flink Maswick Law will be greeting trick or treaters from 3 pm to 5 pm at their Lake Placid, NY Office.
The view from the top of Whiteface Mountain showing the entirety of Lake Placid and mountains.
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC • October 9, 2026
The offices of Flink Maswick Law will be closed on October 12, 2026 for the federal holiday.
Attorney and Partner Molly S Hann of Flink Maswick Law in Lake Placid and Tupper Lake NY
By Flink Maswick Law • September 30, 2026
Attorney Molly Hann shares estate planning strategies with St. Lawrence University alumni to protect family, preserve wealth, and support charitable giving.
Flink Maswick Law team standing in front of Mirror Lake in Lake Placid NY.
By Flink Maswick Law • September 17, 2026
Apply for a full-time Receptionist/Administrative Assistant position at Flink Maswick Law PLLC in Lake Placid, NY. Competitive pay and benefits.
Flag waving with the sky in the background and sun set. Text states
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC • September 11, 2026
A post from Flink Maswick Law in remembrance of 9/11, 25 years later.
Attorneys Ed Flink and Elliot Vanier sitting at a table reviewing documents.
By Flink Maswick Law • September 10, 2026
Attorneys Ed Flink and Elliot Vanier secured a $110,000 settlement for a Capital District client injured as a passenger in a two-car crash.
American Flag waving with text Happy Labor Day and stars.
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC • September 5, 2026
Happy Labor Day Post from Flink Maswick Law with offices in Lake Placid NY, Tupper Lake NY, and Albany NY.
Flink Maswick Law PLLC attorneys, staff, and families at The Wild Center in Tupper Lake.
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC • August 19, 2026
Flink Maswick Law PLLC attorneys, staff, and families enjoyed a summer fun day visiting The Wild Center and its famous trolls in Tupper Lake, NY.
Flink Maswick Law PLLC  attorneys and staff at Mirror Lake in Lake Placid NY
August 12, 2026
Flink Maswick Law PLLC in Lake Placid and Tupper Lake, will close at 11:30 a.m. on Friday, August 14, 2026, for a firm summer fun day and will reopen Monday, August 17 at 8:30 a.m.
Molly Hann, Jill Reynolds (3rd Yar law student), and James Maswick
By Flink Maswick Law • July 17, 2026
The attorneys of Flink Maswick Law PLLC were pleased to host Jill Reynolds, a rising third-year law student at Vermont Law School, this past week. Jill had the opportunity to attend both criminal and civil-based proceedings in a variety of courts, conduct legal research to support Flink Maswick attorneys in some litigated matters, attend client meetings, and sit in and participate on strategy phone calls with clients as well. Jill spent the majority of time with both attorneys Molly S. Hann and James L. Maswick this past week and also met with attorney Edward B. Flink. We greatly enjoyed having Jill and wish them an excellent upcoming third year at Vermont Law! Flink Maswick Law participated in the Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Third Judicial Department's Rural Pathways Program, which is designed to place law students in rural counties during the summer break from school. The program allows students to observe rural law practice, as well as gain hands-on experience in different areas of law in rural settings. One of the goals of the program is to educate law students about opportunities for law students in legal practice in less populated areas.
Show More