What is Fair in Love and War

Madison Marshall, Law Clerk • November 22, 2024

In New York, marriage is seen as more than just a societal standard of a public declaration of love and commitment, but also an economic investment and partnership between the two spouses. A divorce in New York initiates once one spouse brings a lawsuit against the other. While these matters can be resolved in different ways, in many divorces, the division of assets and finances play a significant role in divorce proceedings. With the majority of married couples not having a pre-nuptial agreement prior to getting married, which spells out how assets will be divided if a divorce occurs, an understanding of the process is important.


The divorce process includes the division of assets, called Equitable Distribution, which as a central principle is the ideas of equality and fairness when deciding who is entitled to what property. The goal of Equitable Distribution is to divide Marital Property fairly between the divorcing spouses, with an emphasis on equal monetary value to each divorced spouse, unless a prenuptial agreement says otherwise. There are exceptions in these matters when there are items purchased prior to the marriage or personal gifts or judgments from others outside of the relationship that are awarded during the marriage that are considered separate property and not subject to the principles of equitable distribution.


Under the state’s laws governing Equitable Distribution, property is divided into marital property and separate property. Marital property is typically anything that either spouse purchased or received during the marriage and prior to the execution of a separation or prenuptial agreement, even items that are titled to only one spouse. Retirement or pensions plans can be considered marital property for the purposes of equitable distribution. However, there are exceptions to these general propositions and reputable presumptions.


The Court has significant discretion is determining what is “fair” at times of dividing assets. Factors the Court considers when making these decisions are each spouse’s income, the length of the marriage, each spouse’s age and health, any maintenance awards, if the custodial parent needs to live in or own the marital home, the loss of health benefits from divorce, if there are claims of domestic violence, if there is a companion animal, and any other factor the court seems proper to consider. N.Y. DOM. REL. §236(5)(d)(1)-(16). The Court is to analyze each case based on its own unique facts and consider the lives effected by its decision.


Contact our attorneys at Flink Maswick Law PLLC that handle divorces to speak with us further on how this stage of divorce works.


The foregoing is not to be considered as legal advice and each case contains unique factors which should be considered by your attorney of choice. 

Flag waving with the sky in the background and sun set. Text states
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC September 11, 2026
A post from Flink Maswick Law in remembrance of 9/11, 25 years later.
Attorneys Ed Flink and Elliot Vanier sitting at a table reviewing documents.
By Flink Maswick Law September 10, 2026
Attorneys Ed Flink and Elliot Vanier secured a $110,000 settlement for a Capital District client injured as a passenger in a two-car crash.
American Flag waving with text Happy Labor Day and stars.
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC September 5, 2026
Happy Labor Day Post from Flink Maswick Law with offices in Lake Placid NY, Tupper Lake NY, and Albany NY.
Flink Maswick Law PLLC attorneys, staff, and families at The Wild Center in Tupper Lake.
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC August 19, 2026
Flink Maswick Law PLLC attorneys, staff, and families enjoyed a summer fun day visiting The Wild Center and its famous trolls in Tupper Lake, NY.
Flink Maswick Law PLLC  attorneys and staff at Mirror Lake in Lake Placid NY
August 12, 2026
Flink Maswick Law PLLC in Lake Placid and Tupper Lake, will close at 11:30 a.m. on Friday, August 14, 2026, for a firm summer fun day and will reopen Monday, August 17 at 8:30 a.m.
Molly Hann, Jill Reynolds (3rd Yar law student), and James Maswick
By Flink Maswick Law July 17, 2026
The attorneys of Flink Maswick Law PLLC were pleased to host Jill Reynolds, a rising third-year law student at Vermont Law School, this past week. Jill had the opportunity to attend both criminal and civil-based proceedings in a variety of courts, conduct legal research to support Flink Maswick attorneys in some litigated matters, attend client meetings, and sit in and participate on strategy phone calls with clients as well. Jill spent the majority of time with both attorneys Molly S. Hann and James L. Maswick this past week and also met with attorney Edward B. Flink. We greatly enjoyed having Jill and wish them an excellent upcoming third year at Vermont Law! Flink Maswick Law participated in the Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Third Judicial Department's Rural Pathways Program, which is designed to place law students in rural counties during the summer break from school. The program allows students to observe rural law practice, as well as gain hands-on experience in different areas of law in rural settings. One of the goals of the program is to educate law students about opportunities for law students in legal practice in less populated areas.
James Maswick Attorney and Partner at Flink Maswick Law
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC July 14, 2026
James L. Maswick, an attorney with Flink Maswick Law PLLC, recently was victorious in a New York State Department of Motor Vehicles Refusal Hearing on behalf of a client. Refusal Hearings typically occur when a motorist is arrested and alleged to have been operating their motor vehicle under the influence of alcohol or drugs, and allegedly refuses to provide a chemical test to the police upon proper request. This chemical test can take the form of a breath test, urine test, blood test, and/or a saliva test. In this situation, the client was alleged to have been operating a motor vehicle in an intoxicated condition and allegedly failed to provide a chemical test upon request of the arresting officers. However, Maswick and the client were successful, after three separate refusal hearing sessions, in eliciting testimony on cross-examination from one of the arresting officers, which indicated that the allegations made in the notifications filed with the Department of Motor Vehicles were inaccurate and impossible in light of the arresting officer's own testimony. Upon the start of the third DMV Refusal Hearing session on this matter, the Administrative Law Judge dismissed the case on the motion Mr. Maswick and his client made seeking dismissal of the matter, granting their motion.  If you find yourself in a similar situation, please do not hesitate to contact our firm at (518) 523-2441.
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC July 9, 2026
Flink Maswick Law PLLC is pleased to announce that it was voted runner up by the readers of the Adirondack Daily Enterprise and Lake Placid News in their annual “Best of the Adirondacks” competition for 2026 in the Best Law Firm category. Additionally, Flink Maswick Law PLLC attorney Molly S. Hann, Esq. was voted second place in the Best Attorney/Lawyer competition, after winning the previous 2 years. James L. Maswick, Esq. of Flink Maswick Law PLLC was voted third place in the same category this year. Fellow bar member, colleague and attorney Robert White, Esq. of Saranac Lake and his law firm won Best Attorney/Lawyer and the Best Law Firm categories. Congrats to our friend Bob for his fine work and wins! We wish to thank the readers of the Adirondack Daily Enterprise and Lake Placid News for their continued support and trust. We also congratulate the other award winners and nominees in the annual contest.
Happy 4th of July with fireworks, U.S. flag, and “Celebrating 250 Years of America’s Independence” text
By Flink Maswick Law July 3, 2026
From all of us at Flink Maswick Law, we wish you and your family a safe, happy, and memorable Fourth of July weekend! As we celebrate the freedoms we enjoy and honor those who have served our country, we hope you have the opportunity to relax, spend time with loved ones, and enjoy all that makes this holiday special. Our offices are closed today, Friday, July 3, 2026, in observance of the Independence Day holiday. We will reopen on Monday, July 6, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. Thank you for your continued trust and support. We wish everyone a safe and wonderful holiday! Happy Fourth of July!
By Flink Maswick Law PLLC June 21, 2026
This Father’s Day, all of us at Flink Maswick Law honor the fathers, grandfathers, stepfathers, and father figures who help shape our families and communities throughout the Adirondacks and Upstate New York. Today we celebrate the men who lead by example, offer steady support, share their wisdom, and create lasting memories with those they love. Fathers play an invaluable role in the lives of their families. Whether you’re spending the day fishing, hiking, grilling with family, enjoying time on the lake, or simply relaxing with loved ones, we hope your Father’s Day is filled with laughter, happiness, and special moments.  From all of us in our Lake Placid, Tupper Lake, and Albany offices — Happy Father’s Day!
Show More